提问
盖德化工网  >  盖德问答  >  Angew 申诉两周...

Angew 申诉两周了还没消息?

angew两个审稿人一个important, 一个highly important, 编辑拒稿。我们对审稿意见进行了回复和申诉,说是两周会给消息,但现在也没有收到任何邮件,系统状态也没有改变,这还需要等吗?
0评论 +关注
共7个回答
你的文章几个审稿人?这样一般不会拒
就两个审稿人,第一个审稿人虽然意见里没直接写拒稿,但是填了建议其他杂志,这应该是编辑拒稿的原因吧

1. Please rate the importance of the reported results

Reviewer #1: Important

Reviewer #2: Highly important (top 20%)

--------------------

2. Please indicate whether the results discussed justify publication as a Research Article

Reviewer #1: Publish in another format

Reviewer #2: Publish as a Communication

--------------------

3. Please rate the citation of previous publications

Reviewer #1: Insufficient

Reviewer #2: Insufficient

--------------------

4. Please rate the length of the manuscript

Reviewer #1: Concise

Reviewer #2: Concise

--------------------

5. Please rate the verification of hypotheses and conclusions by the presented data

Reviewer #1: Major inconsistencies

Reviewer #2: Fully consistent

--------------------

6. Please indicate which other journal you consider more appropriate

Reviewer #1: ChemSusChem

Reviewer #2: (No Response)

--------------------

7. Please indicate whether you have included attachments

Reviewer #1: No

Reviewer #2: No

--------------------

8. Please rate the quality of the Supporting Information

Reviewer #1: Satisfactory

Reviewer #2: Satisfactory
没消息就是好消息。不然也很快给你拒了

第一个审稿人给的意见其实比较负面了
有一个important就不行,必须都是前20%
这种情况没有必要进行申诉吧,我觉得要么chemsuschem,要么就CCS Chemistry(或者Chemical Science)试试。
你的文章几个审稿人?这样一般不会拒

貌似仲裁了,等吧2-4周
编辑推荐
三价铬溶液颜色问题? 15个回答
能否用离心代替旋蒸去除乙醇? 2个回答
想请教下靛蓝染料在紫外分光光度计下吸收的问题? 4个回答
硫酸钙结垢,用什么清洗掉? 4个回答
氰基取代苯环上的卤素的反应条件? 0个回答
 
请填写举报原因
选择举报原因
 
增加悬赏
剩余能量值
能量值