提问
盖德化工网  >  盖德问答  >  science ad...

science advance一审审稿意见和编辑意见?

一审18天,审稿意见(审稿人1:小修,但讨论部分比较简单,建议好好改。审稿人2:小修),编辑给potentially interested in publishing the paper 。后续拒稿的的可能性大吗。给6周的修改时间(审稿人说讨论部分简单,但我其实感觉好好写了,大改起来难度还是挺大的,有些担心审稿人1不满意)两个审稿人分别提出了5个和6个问题,个别问题没那么容易回答好。

编辑:Thank you for sending us your manuscript, referenced above. We are pleased to inform you that we are potentially interested in publishing the paper in Science Advances. However, we are not prepared to accept it in its present form and would like you to revise your manuscript in response to reviewer and editorial comments. Your revised manuscript may be sent out for re-review or it may be re-assessed only by the Science Advances editor/s who previously handled it. Please note that if changes do not meet editorial expectations, your manuscript can still be rejected.

审稿人1:The idea is novel and innovative, and the results presented are interesting and worth publishing eventually. A lot of images and observations are compiled, but the discussion at this stage is very crude and does not provide a good understanding of the system. Although I consider the revision to be minor, some of the descriptions or discussions should be seriously revised to provide a better understanding of the results。

审稿人2:Based on the salient features of this work, it can be recommended for publication in Science Advances, but some revisions are recommended, as outlined below
0评论 +关注
共7个回答
几分

楼主是第一次投稿吗 ?
第二次自己投稿

楼主是第一次投稿吗 ?

厉害

整体评价不错,好好根据审稿人的意见修改没问题的。

其实只看编辑的语气基本就是稳了。好好答答应该就可以接收
两个小修,基本没拒稿的可能。至于你觉得没法改得更好的部分,可以请身边的写作高手帮忙看看,讨论讨论,肯定可以写得更好。
编辑推荐
三价铬溶液颜色问题? 15个回答
能否用离心代替旋蒸去除乙醇? 2个回答
想请教下靛蓝染料在紫外分光光度计下吸收的问题? 4个回答
硫酸钙结垢,用什么清洗掉? 4个回答
氰基取代苯环上的卤素的反应条件? 0个回答
 
请填写举报原因
选择举报原因
 
增加悬赏
剩余能量值
能量值